responses

2 files changed, 29 insertions, 0 deletions

diff --git a/doc/forum/debian_backports_update_someone_please.mdwn b/doc/forum/debian_backports_update_someone_please.mdwn
index 46b0aca6b..f1854762e 100644
--- a/doc/forum/debian_backports_update_someone_please.mdwn
+++ b/doc/forum/debian_backports_update_someone_please.mdwn
@@ -5,3 +5,8 @@ I'm just in the process of deploying ikiwiki and I'd love to use it in the html5
 > for 2 weeks. :) --[[Joey]]
 
 >> And are there any chances you doing it... or rather not doing it?
+
+>>> Sure, I'm busily not doing it right now. Should reach testing in 3
+>>> days. I generally schedule things so a new ikiwiki reaches testing
+>>> every 2 weeks to month. Getting important new features and bugfixes out
+>>> can take priority though. --[[Joey]] 
diff --git a/doc/forum/how_do_I_revert_edits_in_the_web_mode__63__.mdwn b/doc/forum/how_do_I_revert_edits_in_the_web_mode__63__.mdwn
index c326b8205..eca572c70 100644
--- a/doc/forum/how_do_I_revert_edits_in_the_web_mode__63__.mdwn
+++ b/doc/forum/how_do_I_revert_edits_in_the_web_mode__63__.mdwn
@@ -3,3 +3,27 @@ Puzzled a bit :-/
 > There is no explicit interface for reverting edits. Most of us use `git revert`. --[[Joey]]
 
 >> That's a blow; I was planning on appointing no techies to keep law and order on our pages :-/ Is there a plugin or at least a plan to add such a 'in demand' feature?
+
+>>> A lot of things complicate adding that feature to the web interface.
+>>>
+>>> First, ikiwiki happily uses whatever the VCS's best of breed web
+>>> history interface is. (ie, viewvcs, gitweb). To allow reverting
+>>> past the bottom of the RecentChanges page, it would need to have its 
+>>> own history browser. Not sure I want to go there.
+>>>
+>>> And the mechanics of handling reverting can quickly get complex. 
+>>> Web reverting should only allow users to revert things they can edit,
+>>> but reverting a whole commit in git might touch multiple files.
+>>> Some files may not be editable over the web at all. (The
+>>> [[tips/untrusted_git_push]] also has to deal with those issues.)
+>>> Finally, a revert can fail with a conflict. The revert could touch 
+>>> multiple files, and multiple ones could conflict. The conflict may
+>>> involve non-page files that can't be diffed. So an interface for
+>>> resolving such a conflict could be hard.
+>>> 
+>>> Probably web-based reverting would need to be limited to reverting 
+>>> single file changes, not whole commits, and not having very good
+>>> conflict handling. And maybe only being accessible for changes
+>>> still visible on RecentChanges. With those limitations, it's certianly
+>>> doable (as a plugin even), but given how excellent `git revert` is in
+>>> comparison, I have not had a real desire to do so. --[[Joey]]